Let me clue you in on our Secret Instructor Language: When your teacher is imploring you to “make a half halt,” what she’s really saying to you is, “For Dog’s sake, DO SOMETHING! DO ANYTHING!”
Category Archives: qotm archives
Past Questions of the Month are listed below in chronological order. Just click on the Question to pull up Bill’s Answers.
With the separation of Edward Gal and Totilas, does Dressage need a new star?
This question is less about a very excellent rider or the magnificent black stallion he thrilled so many people with around the world than it is about marketing. The same sort of question was asked by basketball executives when Michael Jordan retired. More recently, it’s been raised by TV networks and the PGA since Tiger Woods’ career has gone off the rails.
A minor rant on rule changes regarding “Eliminations”
Bill’s angry! What? … Oh, Never mind
Do you care more about points or placings? And what about year-end awards?
BILL—It might be sacrilege. It’s not meant to be sour grapes, but the more I watch and listen over the years, the more specious I think our whole system of awards is. As has been said before by its detractors, dressage competition isn’t a sport. It’s an opinion. The same criticism, of course, could be applied to figure skating, snowboarding, gymnastics, skateboarding, and Dancing with the Stars (although we all know that’s not a sport by anybody’s definition).
When should I start flying changes with my horse?
I always find it unsettling when things that goofy hunter people or kids on fat ponies can do with ease are such crises for dressage riders. One example is flying changes. The problem stems from this—teach your horse to resolutely hold his counter lead for about three years nonstop, and it’s no wonder he things flying changes are off his menu. The solution may seem surprising, but I can provide a long list of luminaries, many with classical backgrounds, who would echo this proposal.
What kind of groundwork do you suggest for most horses?
BILL– From time to time I’ve been known to complain about horses that are “trained” but not “broke,” which is to say, horses that know dressage “things” but don’t behave in a civil manner that should be expected of any horse—even a trail horse or some kid’s fat pony.
A judge commented on my test sheet, “Incorrect salute!” How should I salute properly?
If your judge penalized you for an error, most likely you were nervous and forgot to take your reins in one hand. That is an absolute requirement whether you are male or female—it’s written in the Rulebook. If you didn’t get a “minus two,” your salute probably wasn’t illegal, just unsightly.
My circles to the left bulge out and my circles to the right fall in. What AM I doing wrong exactly and how do I fix it? Karla from Utah
Horses can be more one-sided than the last election! In fact, they usually are. So, one goal of every serious long term schooling program is to make each horse more symmetrical—equally pliable, equally strong in both directions. The situation you’re describing is a horse which is hollow on his left side. This is letting him overbend when tracking left and causing him to fall against your right leg and through his outside shoulder. When you say he falls in going to the right, I’m assuming he also doesn’t bend to the right very well either.
In both cases, he has to learn to respect and move away from your right leg, but let’s examine each direction one at a time.
Every time my instructor asks me to make a renvers, he grabs his head and groans. Why is that? Elizabeth from Ocala
BILL: Pretty good chance it’s because when he asks for a renvers (haunches out), you give him a travers (haunches in). If so, you are not alone in making this mistake. People do this to me all the time because, after all, travers—where you leave the forehand on the track and displace the quarters to the inside, bending your horse
around your inner leg—is the much more common movement.
There are changes in Intro and in the Freestyle requirements too. Any thoughts?
Rest assured if you are a neophyte dressage rider that the changing of the tests, while it may seem to turn your world upside down, will be of lesser consequence than was the introduction of New Coke. The new tests will last longer.