BILL: You’re quite right—there IS something more, and it’s what separates the “interesting” horses from the obedient, cheerful “coasters.” And I was with you right up to the horse’s expression looking “not quite in control.” Then we’re getting towards those flashy models with tail fins and a lot of chrome (that also throw their legs around and can’t stand still at the halt.)
A good rider takes chances and dares to ride the horse nearer “the edge,” but not so near that edge that the aura of harmony and a certain serenity are lost. Sometimes what’s crowd-pleasing because it’s flashy doesn’t (or SHOULDN’T) satisfy the judges if it goes over that line. Striking the best balance between energy/expression and calm confidence is the tactful rider’s art. That’s what we ought to be appreciating as spectators and rewarding as judges.